Fee Download The Memory Keeper's Daughter, by Kim Edwards
This is a few of the benefits to take when being the member as well as obtain the book The Memory Keeper's Daughter, By Kim Edwards right here. Still ask exactly what's various of the other website? We supply the hundreds titles that are created by advised authors as well as authors, around the world. The connect to acquire and also download and install The Memory Keeper's Daughter, By Kim Edwards is likewise extremely easy. You may not locate the complicated website that order to do even more. So, the means for you to get this The Memory Keeper's Daughter, By Kim Edwards will be so simple, will not you?
The Memory Keeper's Daughter, by Kim Edwards
Fee Download The Memory Keeper's Daughter, by Kim Edwards
This is it the book The Memory Keeper's Daughter, By Kim Edwards to be best seller recently. We offer you the most effective deal by obtaining the magnificent book The Memory Keeper's Daughter, By Kim Edwards in this site. This The Memory Keeper's Daughter, By Kim Edwards will certainly not just be the kind of book that is challenging to locate. In this internet site, all types of books are given. You can browse title by title, author by writer, as well as publisher by author to learn the best book The Memory Keeper's Daughter, By Kim Edwards that you could read now.
If you ally need such a referred The Memory Keeper's Daughter, By Kim Edwards book that will certainly provide you worth, get the most effective vendor from us now from many prominent publishers. If you intend to entertaining books, many books, tale, jokes, and a lot more fictions compilations are additionally launched, from best seller to the most recent released. You may not be puzzled to delight in all book collections The Memory Keeper's Daughter, By Kim Edwards that we will certainly offer. It is not about the costs. It's about what you need currently. This The Memory Keeper's Daughter, By Kim Edwards, as one of the most effective sellers below will certainly be one of the right selections to review.
Finding the right The Memory Keeper's Daughter, By Kim Edwards publication as the best need is type of good lucks to have. To begin your day or to finish your day during the night, this The Memory Keeper's Daughter, By Kim Edwards will certainly appertain sufficient. You could merely hunt for the tile right here as well as you will certainly get guide The Memory Keeper's Daughter, By Kim Edwards referred. It will not bother you to reduce your important time to go for purchasing publication in store. This way, you will certainly also spend cash to pay for transportation and other time invested.
By downloading and install the on the internet The Memory Keeper's Daughter, By Kim Edwards book right here, you will get some advantages not to go with the book store. Merely link to the internet and also start to download the page web link we share. Currently, your The Memory Keeper's Daughter, By Kim Edwards prepares to delight in reading. This is your time and also your calmness to get all that you really want from this publication The Memory Keeper's Daughter, By Kim Edwards
- Sales Rank: #2594496 in Books
- Published on: 2006
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Binding: Mass Market Paperback
Most helpful customer reviews
256 of 278 people found the following review helpful.
For such a rich subject...left me completely unmoved
By RMurray847
The initial premise of the book is terrific. We're in the '60s and a doctor finds himself in a situation on a snowy night in which he must deliver his own child, with the help of his nurse Caroline (who has a secret crush on him). The first child, Paul, is healthy, but the second, a girl, is born with Down's Syndrome. The doctor, David, is convinced his wife Norah will not be able to "handle" the trauma of having such a child, so he decides, in an instant, to hand the poor girl to Caroline and asks her to take it to a home for such children and leave it there, never to mention the girl again. He tells his wife that the daughter has died. Caroline runs to the home,finds it to be a hugely disturbing place, and then looking into the face of this new baby, decides she can love the girl and provide her with a life. She runs off with the baby, ready to start a new and uncertain life.
These initial scenes are fairly well done, and though the decision David makes is abhorrent today...it is somewhat tempered by the fact that in the '60s, we as a society weren't quite so compassionate or understanding of folks with Downs. His logic about sparing his wife is questionable, however, and Edwards fairly effectively shows that the gulf between David's initial guilt and wariness about being caught and Norah's grief at losing a child drives the couple further apart. Norah is not allowed to grieve in the way she wants...for example, she isn't allowed to see the body of her lost daughter...for obvious reasons.
Anyway, after this the book falls apart. Author Kim Edwards, it becomes clear, hasn't learned the lesson of "showing us" how people are feeling and thinking, but telling us. We are told over and over that David's secret has blanketed his family, that it's driven him apart from his wife and son. We never really understand specifically how. Does David just act guilty all the time? Does Norah never get over her depression? Is she unable to show love to her son because she wants her daughter? I found the book to be almost completely unconvincing psychologically.
Also, every character in the book (possibly excepting the daughter Phoebe) is hugely UNLIKEABLE and UNSYMPATHETIC. David is simply a pompous jerk. Her makes this huge decision and then can't understand how his lie might effect other people. He just wants his wife to "get over it." Problem is, we see right from the beginning of the book, before the lie even happens, that this is not a happy couple and not one that should ever have married. Norah, the wife, marries David apparently without love for him, and then resents him for being very successful and providing for her and her son the kind of life she married him to get. We also learn a great deal about David's childhood, and none of that rings very true either...the David we see as an adult isn't convincingly the man the young David would have grown up to be.
The son,Paul, is shown as a typical sullen teenager who is not understood by his overbearing father. He escapes to playing guitar, and what do you know...he's practically a genius at that instrument. He talks about music in a way that no real person ever would...only in a way that writer's who can't show us how a person feels but must have them "tell" us.
On the other side of the story, we have the nurse Caroline. She appears to be somewhat heroic, because she does risk a lot to provide a life for Phoebe. Yet we never see the day to day struggles of dealing with a child with Down's Syndrome. Some brief early scenes are all we get...but the structure of the story skips all the day to day details and we see only the "end result,"...which doesn't seem to have been all that difficult...except that the author "tells" us that it was. While Caroline isn't unsympathetic she's just kind of bland and passive.
At one point in the later part of the book, David returns to his old hometown and meets an unusual character. I don't want to spoil it...but let's just say that this person's actions are totally silly at first, and then later this person is clearly meant to cause a seismic shift in the dynamics of David's family...instead we just kind of scratch our heads and wonder at the strangeness of everyone's behavior. I wish I could tell you more...but if you manage to slog your way this far into the book, you should at least have some surprises left.
It took me FOREVER to get through this poorly written, overwraught book. I kept going because it was SUCH a bestseller and so many people liked it. I guess I just totally missed it. I realize I'm asking to get huge amounts of "unhelpful" ratings, but I feel there must be other lone voices out there like me...who just found the book deeply unsatisfactory.
The only reason it gets two stars instead of one is that the initial premise IS original and was done well enough to make me buy the darn book in the first place and continue reading it in the hopes that the author's imagination would once again provide redemption. No such luck.
598 of 669 people found the following review helpful.
Read this, read this, read this!
By K. G Havemann
I don't read a lot of fiction and I most especially do not read romances. I'm not sure how this book is categorized but it is the most compulsively readable, emotional, and memorable book I've read since "Gone With the Wind" over 40 years ago. This is an epic story of a doctor who, in an emotional moment and with all his medical knowledge telling him to protect those he loves, makes a decision that affects him and everyone around him forever. On a blizzardly night in 1964, David Henry helps his wife give birth to twins, one a perfect boy and the other a girl with Downs Syndrome. At that time, imperfect children were "put away" in institutions where they died young and families and friends spoke of them in shame-filled whispers, if at all. David grew up with a very sickly sister whose death at age 12 ended all meaningful life for his parents. With all good intentions of sparing his wife and new son the pain he and his parents endured, he made a fateful decision and told his wife the little girl had died at birth. It was a decision that, once made, could not be redeemed nor remedied. Time inexorably moves away from that moment but, instead of becoming distant, it grows tentacles that seize their beings and influence everything for the next three decades. We learn a photograph can capture a moment but it cannot tell you what encompasses it, what came before and after. It cannot effect change, it cannot correct. One moment, one choice, and an ever-widening circle of consequences, many roads taken and many not.
The writing in The Memory Keeper's Daughter is so well-articulated, the story itself is so engrossing and so different from any I have read before, that hard as I tried to remain disaffected, about 100 pages before the end I felt actual pain knowing there was a last page. As I came to know every nuance of these characters, I wanted to reach into the pages and tell them everything, something, anything, to stop time, to take a different road and change the past, then go on again. Honestly, I have never felt quite this way about a book before.
40 of 46 people found the following review helpful.
Quite possibly the worst "best seller" I've ever forced myself to read
By Linda H. Hill
I seriously can't understand how this book got such glowing reviews and ended up a best seller. I purchased the paperback at an airport based on the description on the back cover and front-cover praise from Sue Monk Kidd. I feel I have been deceived.
If this had been a book written with 6th-10th-graders in mind, I might understand the appeal, but for adults, there very little new here and what little there was was diminished by unrelenting repetition to the point where it felt as though it were being shoved down my throat. As if the author wanted to scream at me, "Get it?! Do you GET IT?! Let me say it one more time so I AM CERTAIN THAT YOU GET IT!!!"
Don't even get me started on the unnecessary descriptive detail that added nothing but words to the pages while characters languished undeveloped--two-dimensional, clich�, pop-psychology placeholders dutifully fulfilling their assigned roles.
Light switches that "give in to touch", the colors of the women's clothing (for all the allusions to feminism in this book, I don't recall the same amount of attention paid to the male characters' clothing), the way sunlight dances...a little of that goes a long way. It reminds me of 9th grade English teachers who remind students to include "lots of the rich description" in their stories--as if the fact that Phoebe's dress was "silvery green" and she carried daffodils "loosely in her right hand" mattered one whit. I want to know what Pheobe thinks, how she feels, not what color her dress is or what kind of flowers she's carrying or in what hand and how. But apparently, beyond her desire to not be whisked off somewhere with strangers and her distaste for escargot, Pheobe has very few thoughts, feelings or opinions. She may have Downs', but surely her head is more than an empty cookie jar.
This book could have been so much more than it was. After the first half, I knew it wasn't going to get better, and it didn't. It actually got worse. But like a train wreck, I couldn't stop looking.
The Memory Keeper's Daughter, by Kim Edwards PDF
The Memory Keeper's Daughter, by Kim Edwards EPub
The Memory Keeper's Daughter, by Kim Edwards Doc
The Memory Keeper's Daughter, by Kim Edwards iBooks
The Memory Keeper's Daughter, by Kim Edwards rtf
The Memory Keeper's Daughter, by Kim Edwards Mobipocket
The Memory Keeper's Daughter, by Kim Edwards Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar